Menu ≡

The Rising Cost of Property Insurance – and What It Means for Landlords and Tenants

The Rising Cost of Property Insurance—and What It Means for Landlords and Tenants

Property insurance used to be a predictable line item. Premiums rose slowly, coverage was relatively stable, and renewals were routine. That era is over.

Across many markets, property insurance costs are rising sharply, policies are becoming more restrictive, and some insurers are exiting entire regions altogether. For landlords, this is squeezing operating margins and forcing tough decisions. For tenants, insurance costs—though often invisible—are increasingly influencing rents, fees, and housing availability.

Understanding what’s driving insurance costs up, how it affects property operations, and what landlords and tenants can realistically do about it is critical in today’s rental market.

Why Property Insurance Costs Are Rising So Fast

Insurance pricing is based on risk, and insurers believe property risk has increased significantly in recent years. Several factors are driving this shift.

1. Climate-Related Risks Are Reshaping Insurance Models

Extreme weather events are no longer isolated incidents. Floods, wildfires, hurricanes, heat waves, and severe storms are occurring more frequently and causing greater damage.

From an insurer’s perspective:

  • Claims are more frequent

  • Claims are more expensive

  • Losses are harder to predict

As a result, insurers are:

  • Raising premiums

  • Increasing deductibles

  • Limiting coverage

  • Declining to renew policies in high-risk areas

Even properties that haven’t experienced damage are affected, as insurers price risk regionally—not individually.

2. Construction and Repair Costs Have Skyrocketed

Insurance claims are based on replacement cost, not market value. When construction costs rise, so do insurance payouts.

Key cost drivers include:

  • Labor shortages

  • Higher material prices

  • Supply chain disruptions

  • Stricter building codes

A claim that might have cost $50,000 to repair a decade ago can now cost double—or more. Insurers pass these increased costs directly to property owners.

3. Legal and Liability Exposure Is Increasing

Liability claims are becoming more complex and expensive.

Examples include:

  • Slip-and-fall lawsuits

  • Mold and habitability claims

  • Fire and safety litigation

  • Accessibility and discrimination claims

Larger settlements and legal costs push insurers to raise premiums or narrow coverage, particularly for multi-unit residential and commercial properties.

4. Insurers Are Pulling Back From Certain Markets

In some regions, insurers aren’t just raising prices—they’re leaving.

This leads to:

  • Fewer coverage options

  • Less competition

  • Higher premiums

  • More restrictive terms

When insurance becomes harder to obtain, landlords may be forced into high-cost specialty markets or state-backed insurance programs with limited coverage.

How Rising Insurance Costs Affect Landlords

Insurance isn’t optional. Lenders require it, municipalities often mandate it, and operating without coverage exposes owners to catastrophic risk.

As premiums rise, landlords face several challenges.

1. Shrinking Operating Margins

Insurance is a fixed cost. When it increases, landlords must absorb the cost, offset it elsewhere, or pass it on.

For properties with:

  • Rent controls

  • Long-term leases

  • Fixed operating expense caps

There may be little room to recover rising insurance costs, directly impacting profitability.

2. Rent Pricing Pressure

In many cases, insurance increases are factored into rent decisions—either immediately or over time.

This can result in:

  • Higher renewal rents

  • Reduced concessions

  • Increased fees (where allowed)

  • Less flexibility in negotiations

Landlords aren’t raising rents because they want to—they’re often responding to higher baseline costs.

3. Changes to Lease Structures

In commercial properties especially, landlords may:

  • Adjust operating expense pass-throughs

  • Clarify insurance allocation in leases

  • Shift more risk to tenants

  • Increase CAM (Common Area Maintenance) charges

In residential settings, landlords may tighten lease terms or reduce included services to manage rising costs.

4. Delayed Maintenance and Capital Improvements (A Risky Tradeoff)

Some landlords attempt to offset insurance increases by cutting costs elsewhere—often maintenance or upgrades.

This can backfire:

  • Deferred maintenance increases claim risk

  • Poor conditions raise liability exposure

  • Insurers may deny coverage or increase premiums further

Ironically, cutting maintenance to save money can make insurance even more expensive.

How Rising Insurance Costs Affect Tenants

Tenants rarely see insurance bills, but they still feel the impact.

1. Higher Rents and Fewer Discounts

Insurance increases contribute to:

  • Rent increases at renewal

  • Fewer move-in incentives

  • Less flexibility in negotiations

Even modest rent increases may reflect significant insurance cost jumps behind the scenes.

2. Reduced Property Services or Amenities

To control costs, landlords may:

  • Scale back amenities

  • Delay upgrades

  • Reduce on-site staffing

  • Limit discretionary improvements

Tenants may experience fewer “extras” even if rent stays relatively stable.

3. Tighter Lease Terms and Policies

Increased insurance scrutiny can lead landlords to:

  • Enforce rules more strictly

  • Restrict pets or certain uses

  • Require higher tenant insurance coverage

  • Limit risky behaviors (e.g., grills, candles, certain equipment)

These changes are often driven by insurer requirements rather than landlord preference.

What Landlords Can Do to Manage Insurance Costs

While landlords can’t control global insurance markets, they can manage risk—and insurers reward that.

1. Invest in Risk Mitigation

Insurers favor properties that proactively reduce risk.

Examples include:

  • Updated electrical systems

  • Modern plumbing

  • Fire suppression systems

  • Secure entry and lighting

  • Roof and drainage maintenance

  • Water leak detection devices

These upgrades can lower premiums, reduce claims, and prevent catastrophic losses.

2. Improve Documentation and Maintenance Records

Insurers increasingly request evidence of good management.

Keeping records of:

  • Inspections

  • Repairs

  • Safety upgrades

  • Preventive maintenance

can improve underwriting outcomes and strengthen renewal negotiations.

3. Work With Specialized Insurance Brokers

Not all brokers understand rental properties equally.

A broker who specializes in:

  • Multifamily

  • Commercial real estate

  • Regional risk profiles

can often find better coverage structures, identify gaps, and negotiate more effectively.

4. Review Coverage Annually—Not Automatically

Automatic renewals can be costly.

Landlords should:

  • Review deductibles

  • Reassess coverage limits

  • Understand exclusions

  • Compare alternatives

In some cases, higher deductibles paired with strong reserves can reduce premiums significantly.

5. Align Maintenance and Insurance Strategies

Insurance and property management shouldn’t operate in silos.

Proactive maintenance:

  • Reduces claim frequency

  • Improves insurer confidence

  • Protects long-term asset value

A well-maintained property is almost always cheaper to insure.

What Tenants Can Do to Protect Themselves

Tenants can’t control property insurance—but they can reduce their own risk.

1. Carry Adequate Renter’s or Commercial Tenant Insurance

Landlord insurance does not cover tenant belongings or many tenant-related liabilities.

Tenant insurance can cover:

  • Personal property loss

  • Liability claims

  • Temporary housing after a loss

As landlords tighten insurance requirements, tenant coverage is becoming standard.

2. Understand Lease Insurance Clauses

Tenants should review:

  • Insurance requirements

  • Liability provisions

  • Indemnification clauses

Understanding these terms helps avoid surprises after an incident.

3. Report Maintenance Issues Promptly

Unreported issues—like leaks or electrical problems—can escalate into major losses.

Prompt reporting:

  • Reduces damage

  • Protects tenant belongings

  • Limits liability disputes

  • Improves insurer outcomes for the property

Insurance Costs and the Housing Affordability Conversation

Rising insurance costs are increasingly part of the housing affordability puzzle.

When operating costs rise:

  • Rents increase

  • New development slows

  • Older properties struggle to remain viable

  • Insurance availability affects housing supply

This creates a feedback loop where risk, cost, and affordability intersect—often in ways that impact tenants most.

Residential vs. Commercial Insurance Impacts

Residential Properties

  • Premium increases often spread across units

  • Rent controls may limit cost recovery

  • Liability and habitability claims are major drivers

Commercial Properties

  • Insurance costs are more often passed through

  • Tenants may share risk directly

  • Coverage requirements are more complex

In both cases, insurance is no longer a background issue—it’s a strategic concern.

The Long-Term Outlook

Most experts agree that:

  • Insurance costs are unlikely to return to previous lows

  • Climate risk will continue influencing premiums

  • Risk mitigation will play a larger role in pricing

  • Properties that adapt will fare better than those that don’t

Landlords who ignore insurance trends risk sudden cost spikes or loss of coverage altogether.

Final Thoughts

The rising cost of property insurance is reshaping rental housing—quietly but powerfully. For landlords, it challenges profitability and operational planning. For tenants, it influences rents, policies, and housing availability in ways that aren’t always obvious.

Insurance is no longer just a requirement—it’s a signal. It reflects how risky a property is perceived to be, how well it’s managed, and how prepared it is for the future.

Landlords who invest in risk reduction, transparency, and proactive management will be better positioned to control costs and protect their assets. Tenants who understand the role insurance plays can make smarter housing decisions and protect themselves financially.

In today’s rental market, insurance isn’t just about protection—it’s about sustainability, stability, and long-term viability for everyone involved.

#propertymanagement #rentalproperty #landlordtips #tenanttips #apartmentliving #rentalmaintenance #realestateadvice #rentalhousing #EmilyShortall #EmilyGoodmanShortall